Those who forget their history are condemned to repeat it, whoever said it, said it right!

By
Prashant Hamine
-
63
546

X: @prashanthamine

 “Those who forget their history are condemned to repeat it”, this famous quote is often attributed to the philosopher George Santayana. Critics argue that it is actually a misquotation of his comment, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” Then the famous quote “Those that fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it” – is also attributed to former, late British Prime Minister Winston Churchill who is widely believed to have said it in 1948.

Whosoever, might have said it, has said it right.

There is a raging controversy going on over the depiction of Mughal and Maratha history in the just released Vicky Kaushal starrer historical Biopic “Chhaava”, produced by Laxman Utekar.

When it comes to producing historical Bio-pics our producers, directors have often in the name of cinematic liberties have often transgressed the thin line between history and fiction. Chhaava, initially was no exception, after a brief uproar over depiction of Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj in some scenes in the movie, the uproar died down following some strong political intervention from Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNNS) chief Raj Thackeray

One might take the example of the 1982 Richard Attenborough’s historical Biopic “Gandhi”, on Mahatma Gandhi. Or the 2023 Christopher Nolan’s Bio-pic “Oppenheimer”, on the life of the modern-day father of the atomic bomb.

But when it comes to revered historical icons like Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj or Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj, there is little or no scope left for any cinematic liberties as it is bound to hurt the sensibilities of their ardently devout followers. As the makers of the 2018 Bollywood Biopic “Padmaavat” found much to their chagrin.

A similar situation had arisen with the 2015 Bollywood flick “Bajirao Mastani”, where more than the military exploits of Bajirao Peshwa I, the film chose to focus more on romanticising his personal relations.

Another important aspect that the government needs to seriously look at is to preserve the forts built by Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj, Maharana Pratap and ancient kings and queens.

Right now some of the forts built by Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj are in ruins and in urgent need of restoration. If this historical legacy is lost forever, it will be an irreparable loss for which history might not forgive us at all. Mere paying lip-service towards building world’s tallest statues of our icons is not enough, some doable actions in conserving the legacy that they left behind is the need of the hour.

Besides the often misinterpretation of our history in the name of cinematic liberty, the controversy has reopened the debate over what is now being called as hiding our history from plain sight. History of ancient India did exist much before the advent of the Moghul invaders, or the colonial powers like the British, the Portuguese, the French or the Dutch in some cases.

People have every right to know their factual history and that of their revered icons as they and the nation seeks to reclaim its lost historical and cultural identity from the clutches of marauding invaders or past colonial masters. There is now a growing demand from the former colonies, of their former colonial masters for Reparations, for the loot and plunder of their resources thereby pushing back their economic and infrastructure development.

It is also high time that the colonial powers return the looted treasures back to their former colonies. Preserving their colonial loot in their museums is in a way an admission of their past colonial crimes for which they need to return back the looted treasure.

Governments till date have often used the Official Secrets Act (OSA), 1923 and National Security Act (NSA), 1980 to push anything they view as uncomfortable or might cause social tensions, under the carpet. Then there have been contentious laws and prolonged legal battles that have only added more into vitiating the social atmosphere.

The excuse that opening up past history might reignite social tensions, is debatable argument. It has been 78 years since Independence in 1948. That is roughly 3.9 or close to 4 generations. Generations are one way to group age cohorts. A generation typically refers to groups of people born over a 15 to 20 year span.

Present generation and generations to come need to be made aware of their past history and their legacy. A disconnect with one’s past history does not augur well for the future as a society and as a nation. To think that the present generation might view history entirely differently in the present context, is debatable.

It also does not bode well to cast doubt on the present generation’s ability to take historical facts in their strides. There is a generational shift in every 15 to 20 years, four generations have passed since 1947, and another 22 years to go before we celebrate 100 years of our Independence in 2047.

US President Donald Trump has announced that he will declassify the Kennedy assassination files, 62 years after the assassination of former late US President John F Kennedy, that is 3 (3.1) generations later. The Prime Minister Narendra Modi led administration too has declassified some files relating to Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose with not much of a controversy.

The Nuremberg Trials held between November 20, 1945 and October 1, 1946, by the International Military Tribunal (IMT) tried 22 of the most important surviving leaders of Nazi Germany in the political, military, and economic spheres, as well as six German organizations. It did bring some closure to the victims and their families who had suffered during World War II at the hands of Nazi Germany.

Similarly, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) was a court-like restorative justice body assembled in South Africa in 1996 after the end of Apartheid. Authorised by Nelson Mandela and chaired by Archbishop Desmond Tutu the commission invited witnesses who were identified as victims of gross human rights violations to give statements about their experiences, and selected some for public hearings. Perpetrators of violence could also give testimony and request amnesty from both civil and criminal prosecution.

As a nation we too have quite a few scares and wounds to heal. Be it the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, also known as the Amritsar massacre that took place on 13 April 1919. The Noakhali massacre of October-November 1946 and the Moplah/Malabar massacre or rebellion of 1921, to name a few.

We too need to offload the burden of history, just like the Nuremberg Trials or the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Often past history teaches one a lot in understanding the context, correcting the past mistakes, making course corrections and moving on. It is high time that the truth comes out, so that the old wounds heal and we as a nation move forwards towards lasting peace, prosperity and inclusive development.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

63 COMMENTS

  1. Somebody essentially help to make significantly articles Id state This is the first time I frequented your web page and up to now I surprised with the research you made to make this actual post incredible Fantastic job

  2. A person essentially help to make seriously posts I would state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the research you made to create this particular publish amazing. Magnificent job!

  4. wonderful post, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector don’t notice this. You should continue your writing. I’m confident, you have a huge readers’ base already!

  31. Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways, just wanted to say superb blog!

  34. I’ve been surfing on-line more than three hours lately, but I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours. It is beautiful worth sufficient for me. In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made just right content material as you did, the internet will probably be much more helpful than ever before.

  35. What i do not understood is actually how you are not really much more well-liked than you might be now. You’re so intelligent. You realize therefore considerably relating to this subject, produced me personally consider it from a lot of varied angles. Its like women and men aren’t fascinated unless it’s one thing to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. Always maintain it up!

  52. Alle neuen Kundinnen und Kunden können sich im Verde
    Casino über einen tollen Willkommensbonus freuen, denn hier gibt es maximal 1.200 Euro Bonusguthaben und
    220 Freispiele für verschiedene beliebte Slots zu ergattern. Wer ohnehin keine Slots mag, kann
    im Verde Casino natürlich auch klassische Tischspiele wie
    Roulette oder Black Jack spielen – auf Wunsch in der Standardvariante oder als
    Live-Game gegen einen echten Dealer. In unserem heutigen Casino Bonus Test beschäftigen wir uns mit dem brandneuen Verde Casino Bonus Code, das seinen neuen Kundinnen und Kunden einen überraschend hohen Willkommensbonus anbietet.
    Die große Mehrheit der Bonuscodes bei Verde Casino kann
    nur einmal pro Konto angewendet werden. Nachdem sie alle Varianten möglicher verlockender Bonuscodes gesehen haben, verirren sich Spieler,
    insbesondere Anfänger, in der großen Vielfalt und nutzen sie oft nicht richtig.

    Da der kostenlose Bonus keine Einzahlung voraussetzt,
    können Sie die VerdeCasino Freispiele ohne finanzielles Risiko in Empfang nehmen und vollkommen kostenlos verwenden. Wie üblich für diese Art
    von Online Slots erhält der Nutzer nach der Auslösung des Bonus-Spiels ein zufälliges Symbol, welches sich im Rahmen der Freispiele ausklappt.
    Um das Bonus-Feature des Spiels auslösen zu können,
    müssen Sie innerhalb einer Umdrehung mindestens drei
    Scatter-Symbole erhalten. Die Verde Casino 50 Freispiele
    werden Ihnen also vollkommen kostenfrei gutgeschrieben. Nachdem Sie
    die Casino Verde Freispiele aktiviert haben, müssen einige Bedingungen erfüllt werden, bevor Sie die
    Auszahlung in Form von echtem Geld beantragen können. Hier erhalten die Spieler abhängig von ihren Einsätzen, die in der letzten Woche getätigt worden sind, einen weiteren Bonus.

    Diese Codes gewähren zusätzliche Vorteile über
    das reguläre Willkommensangebot hinaus, wie zusätzliches Startguthaben oder
    Freispiele, was Ihre Gewinnchancen erhöht. Hinzu kommt eine
    riesige Anzahl von Freispielen für unterschiedliche Slots.Außerdem
    veranstaltet das Verde Casino regelmäßige Aktionen und stellt ein Treueprogramm zur Verfügung.
    Wenn Sie im VerdeCasino 50 Freispiele für den Slot Book of
    Sirens erhalten, können Sie sich also auf jede Menge Spielspaß an diesem
    Automaten freuen.

  53. Der CasinoBuck Neukundenbonus umfasst einen Ersteinzahlungsbonus von 100% bis 100€ mit 100 Freispielen.
    Der Goodman Casino Bonus bietet dir einen Ersteinzahlungsbonus von 100% bis 100€ + 100 Freispiele.

    Sie merken bestimmt den großen Unterschied, denn
    hier spielen Sie live, also mit echten Mitspielern und echten Dealern!
    Der Umsatzbedingte Willkommensbonus besteht aus 3 separaten Einzahlungsboni mit einem Gesamtwert von bis zu 1.700€ + 300 Freispielen, die der Reihe nach abgespielt werden. Du bekommst zwölf Freispiele und kannst in den Freispielen mit dem Horus-Symbol weitere
    kostenlose Runden gewinnen. Probiere es aus, denn du kannst online
    Eye of Horus kostenlos spielen.
    Durch die Eingabe des Bonus Codes “300WAGER”
    und eine Mindesteinzahlung von 100€ erhältst
    du einen 300% Bonus bis zu 600€ und weitere 100 Freispiele für
    Ramses Treasure. Gib den Bonuscode “200WAGER” ein und tätige
    eine Mindesteinzahlung von 50€, um einen 200% Bonus bis zu 600€ und
    100 Freispiele für Ramses Treasure zu erhalten. Vor allem Slots lassen sich am mobilen Gerät
    sehr entspannt spielen. Wenn Du von unterwegs im Horus Casino spielen möchtest, kannst Du sofort loslegen. Somit
    kannst Du beispielsweise sogar 10 Cent Roulette spielen oder Dich an verschiedenen Gameshows amüsieren.
    Die kannst auch Eye of Horus im Casino kostenlos spielen – Empfehlungen findest du weiter unten im Beitrag.
    Diese Funktionen stehen dir natürlich auch dann zur Verfügung, wenn du
    dich dafür entscheidest, Eye of Horus gratis zu spielen. So kannst du
    Eye of Horus gratis und auch legal spielen. Nein, das Spiel
    hat keine eigene App – aber es ist über viele Casino-Apps kostenfrei spielbar, oft sogar im Demo-Modus oder mit Freispielen zum Start.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/f1-casino-auszahlung-ein-umfassender-guide-fur-spieler/

  54. Bond soon learns that the funds were never deposited in the Treasury’s
    account and discovers Vesper taking the money to a mysterious organisation only vaguely
    alluded to throughout the film. Leiter, who is also
    undercover playing the game, feels that Bond can beat
    Le Chiffre and gives him the $5 million. Vesper refuses to grant Bond the $5 million necessary to re-buy, so he decides to assassinate Le Chiffre,
    but American CIA agent Felix Leiter intervenes. During the game, Bond discovers the poker tell that Le Chiffre commits
    when he is bluffing.
    Casino Royale was first released on 13 April 1953 in the UK as a hardback edition by publishers Jonathan Cape, with a cover devised by Fleming.
    Black also identifies a mechanism Fleming uses in Casino Royale—and in subsequent Bond
    novels—which is to use the evil of his opponents both as
    a justification of his actions, and as a device to foil their own plans.
    Thus Lycett observes that Casino Royale can be seen as Fleming’s “attempt to reflect the disturbing moral ambiguity of a post-war world that could produce traitors like Burgess and Maclean”.

    Britain had also suffered from defections to the Soviet Union from two MI6 operatives who were part of the Cambridge Five spy ring that betrayed Western secrets
    to the Soviets.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/get-up-to-4000-bonus-ultimate-aussie-gaming-experience/

  55. Let’s start with our experts’ choice of the top AU casino sites to play at legally.
    Many sites also feature specialty games such as bingo,
    keno, and scratch cards. E-wallets and cryptocurrencies typically offer the fastest withdrawals for Australian players.

    If issues remain unresolved, players can contact the casino’s licensing authority.
    Creating an account is necessary for depositing funds,
    claiming bonuses, and withdrawing winnings. Many international sites welcome
    Australian players operating in a legal grey area.
    If you’re into straightforward gameplay, try some of the best online pokies.
    Here’s a quick recap of our top five Australian online casino sites to help you decide.
    Most online gambling sites support a wide range of payment options,
    including bank transfers, crypto, card, and e-wallets
    — all of which offer fast turnaround times.
    Bonanza and Extra Chilli are two of their most popular games, and they’ve stayed favourites with Aussie players for years.
    For anyone who wants the closest thing to a land-based casino from home,
    Evolution is the gold standard at any live online casino Australia.

    Mega Moolah is probably their most famous title at top online casino sites in Australia, with prize pools climbing into the millions.

    For example, some live blackjack games offer side bets like Perfect
    Pairs and 21+3, while Lightning Roulette adds multipliers for higher volatility and
    bigger payouts. These TV-show-style games involve dice, lottery-style draws, money wheels, and even fishing, with bonus rounds, multipliers, and unlimited seating built in. A
    controlled dice mechanism ensures fairness, and beginner-friendly tutorials built into some games help new players quickly learn the
    basics.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/ws-casino-australia-full-review/

  56. The season will conclude next week in Chicago against
    the Bears, where the most Detroit can do is try to play spoiler for their Ben Johnson and their
    NFC North rivals. There are significant decisions to be made
    along the offensive line with Glasgow and left tackle Taylor Decker.
    But there were some cruel closes calls — the controversial,
    1-yard-away loss to the Steelers comes to mind — that also cost
    Detroit. The Lions are also just 2-5 in one-possession games this
    season after going 7-2 in those games in 2024.
    How serious are the Bears as playoff contenders? With
    two weeks to go, the 2025 NFL playoff picture
    is already relatively clear. Green Bay Packers clinch playoff berth with Vikings’ win over Lions on Christmas
    This post will update with inactives, pregame updates, drive summaries, injury
    updates and more.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/play-at-wild-fortune-online-casino/

  57. From fair payouts to smooth gameplay and local support,
    everything is built with the Australian player in mind.
    Combining cheerful visuals with serious rewards, it’s a
    platform that treats every player like a VIP. The experience is fluid, colorful and bursting with energy — mobile play that’s every bit as sweet as the
    main site. From first deposit to final cashout, everything runs as smoothly as syrup — giving
    Aussie players the confidence to enjoy every moment of play.
    Big Candy Casino makes transactions smooth, safe and sugar-sweet for Australian players.

    Navigation is effortless, with clearly labeled categories for
    online pokies australia, table games, and live
    dealer experiences that put you in control from the first click.
    The platform’s vibrant candy-themed design creates an inviting
    atmosphere while maintaining professional functionality that Australian players demand.

    Whether you’re spinning classic fruit machines or chasing progressive jackpots, this platform solidifies itself as a top choice for
    discerning Australian players.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/the-best-australian-mobile-casinos-2025/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here