Maharashtra’s World Bank Loan Trap: Case Studies of Costly Projects

By
Vivek Bhavsar
-
16
544

X: @vivekbhavsar

Part 3 – Case Studies

Behind Maharashtra’s ballooning debt to the World Bank lie projects that were launched with fanfare and lofty promises. On paper, they looked transformative. In reality, they have morphed into decades-long fiscal liabilities, draining the state treasury year after year.

1. Climate Resilient Agriculture Project (2018)

Sanctioned in 2018 at ₹2,930 crore, this was promoted as a visionary scheme to help farmers adapt to climate change. Yet, in just a few years, it has turned into Maharashtra’s costliest World Bank loan.

  • Repayments: Only recently begun, but will drag on well into the 2030s.
  • Interest: A staggering ₹226 crore in 2024–25 alone — enough to fund multiple state-level schemes.
  • Commitment Charges: ₹7.42 crore in 2020–21, paid merely because funds weren’t drawn on schedule.

A project meant to shield farmers from shocks has instead become a fiscal shock for the state. The all-in cost is likely to overshoot the original sanction by 40–50%, raising the question: could domestic borrowing have achieved the same objectives at far lower cost?

Also Read: Maharashtra’s World Bank Loan Trap: Hidden Costs Bleeding the State

Mini Case Study 1 – Climate Resilient Agriculture (8829-IN)

  • Sanctioned Loan: ₹2,930 crore (2018)
  • Repayments so far: ~₹1,200 crore
  • Interest Paid: ₹226 crore in 2024–25 alone
  • All-In Cost: On track to exceed sanction by 40–50%

2. Mumbai Urban Transport Project – MUTP 2A (2010)

Billed as a flagship upgrade for Mumbai’s overloaded suburban rail system, this ₹638 crore loan sanctioned in 2010 was meant to ease commuter woes. Fifteen years later, it is a classic debt sinkhole.

  • Repayments: Peaked at over ₹40 crore annually in the late 2010s.
  • Interest: Relentlessly climbed, touching ₹49 crore in 2024–25.
  • Total Burden: Repayments plus interest have already pushed the real cost beyond ₹1,000 crore.

Despite this crushing bill, Mumbai’s trains remain crowded, delayed, and dangerous. For commuters, little has changed — except that taxpayers now carry a debt burden that far outstripped the sanctioned figure.

Mini Case Study 2 – Mumbai Urban Transport Project 2A (7941-IN)

  • Sanctioned Loan: ₹1,800 crore (2010)
  • Repayments so far: ~₹850 crore
  • Interest Paid: Nearly ₹49 crore in 2024–25 alone
  • All-In Cost: Already above ₹1,000 crore and still rising

3. Maharashtra Water Sector Improvement Project (2005)

Launched with a ₹1,438 crore sanction in 2005, this project was supposed to modernise irrigation and water use efficiency. Instead, it locked Maharashtra into a repayment treadmill that continues two decades later.

  • Repayments: Rising steadily, nearing ₹150 crore per year by 2019–20.
  • Interest: Adding another ₹30 crore annually.
  • Commitment Charges: Persistent, further inflating the bill.
Government of Maharashtra Loan Repayments (2010–2011 to 2019–2020): World Bank and IDA loans worth ₹55,360 crore repaid under Mumbai Sewage Disposal, Maharashtra Water Sector Improvement, Sustainable Urban Transport, Agricultural Competitiveness and other major projects. Source: Aid, Accounts & Audit Division, Ministry of Finance.

(Disclaimer: All figures are taken directly from official repayment schedules obtained under RTI from the Aid, Accounts & Audit Division, Ministry of Finance, Government of India. Calculations and conversions from billion to crore have been cross-verified)

Yet, farmers in drought-prone districts like Marathwada still struggle for reliable irrigation. For them, the only thing flowing consistently is repayment money to the World Bank.

Mini Case Study 3 – Water Sector Improvement Project (4796-IN)

  • Sanctioned Loan: ~₹1,400 crore (2005)
  • Repayments so far: ~₹700 crore
  • Interest Paid: ₹20–25 crore annually in peak years
  • All-In Cost: Projected 30–40% above sanction

4. Legacy Burdens: The Ghost of Old Loans

Even “emergency” and “one-time” loans have haunted the state’s balance sheet for decades.

  • Earthquake Emergency Program (1994): Meant for post-Latur quake relief, it still demanded repayments and interest long after the victims had moved on with life.
  • Jalswarajya Rural Water Supply Project (2003): Designed to deliver clean drinking water, it dragged Maharashtra into costly repayments well into the late 2010s, with costs ballooning instead of tapering.

These “ghost loans” expose how temporary assistance routinely morphs into decades of financial bondage.

Also Read: Maharashtra’s World Bank Loan Trap: The True Cost of Borrowing

Case Study Takeaway

Every case tells the same story: while repayments look predictable on paper, it is the interest and commitment charges that silently multiply the burden. By the time citizens judge whether these projects delivered on their promises, the financial costs are already locked in for a generation.

Government of Maharashtra Loan Repayments (2010–2011 to 2019–2020): World Bank and IDA loans worth ₹55,360 crore repaid under Mumbai Sewage Disposal, Maharashtra Water Sector Improvement, Sustainable Urban Transport, Agricultural Competitiveness and other major projects. Source: Aid, Accounts & Audit Division, Ministry of Finance.

(Disclaimer: All figures are taken directly from official repayment schedules obtained under RTI from the Aid, Accounts & Audit Division, Ministry of Finance, Government of India. Calculations and conversions from billion to crore have been cross-verified)

👉 Coming up in Part 4: A decade-wise breakdown of Maharashtra’s rising World Bank costs, exposing how interest and hidden fees quietly double the burden.

Annexure – C1 Repayment from 2000-2001 to 2009-2010Download
Annexure- C2 Repayment from 2010-2011 to 2019-2020Download

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

16 COMMENTS

  12. Schlafzimmer Hier können Sie enge Kopfsteinpflasterstraßen, traditionelle Geschäfte und lokale Restaurants erkunden. Machen Sie eine Fahrt den Hügel hinauf nach Monte
    und genießen Sie einen Panoramablick auf Funchal
    und die umliegenden Gebiete. Es ist ein großartiger Ort, um einen gemütlichen Spaziergang zu machen und die lebendige Atmosphäre zu genießen. Dieser Bereich eignet sich perfekt
    für Spaziergänge am Wasser und um die wunderschöne Aussicht zu genießen.
    Ja, das Pestana Casino Park liegt in unmittelbarer Nähe zum Stadtzentrum von Funchal, was es für Gäste praktisch macht, verschiedene Sehenswürdigkeiten und Annehmlichkeiten zu erkunden. Ja, das Hotel bietet verschiedene Freizeiteinrichtungen wie einen Swimmingpool, ein Spa- und Wellnesscenter, ein Fitnessstudio
    und einen Tennisplatz. Genießen Sie lokale Musiker, die traditionelle Musik spielen, oder zeitgenössische Bands, die verschiedene Genres spielen. Durch die erstklassige Lage
    in Funchal können die Gäste die schöne Stadt erkunden und einen angenehmen Aufenthalt genießen.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/wazamba-casino-aktionscodes-ihr-schlussel-zu-aufregenden-boni/

  13. Thus, the Casino Mate online casino is not limited to games for computers only.

    If gambling feels like more than just entertainment, Casino
    Mate offers responsible gaming tools like deposit limits, self-exclusion, and play
    reminders. Join Casino Mate today—Australia’s trusted online casino—and experience
    a world where responsible gaming and thrilling entertainment
    go hand in hand. All deposits at Casino Mate are processed instantly with no added
    fees, allowing players to dive straight into their favorite
    games with minimal hassle. This bonus keeps your game lively and exciting with extra playing time.
    With a world of exciting games at your fingertips and the potential
    for real money wins, Casino Mate is your perfect
    gaming mate.
    Let’s say right away that 90% of devices allow you to gamble in the Casino Mate mobile casino.

    The next thing you will need is a device through which
    you can gamble in games with HTML5. Nowadays, plenty of Aussies play
    on our site from iOS or Android mobile devices.
    This is a real money casino which also offers free games for those
    who want to trial titles before placing real
    money wagers, or simply like to play on a recreational level.

    You’ll find a huge range of real money pokies, classic table games like blackjack and roulette, live dealer options, jackpots,
    and more. With a laid-back vibe, fast payouts, and a platform that actually works smoothly on both desktop and mobile – this is where Aussies come to play.Stick around as
    we dive into everything Mate has to offer – from bonuses and
    pokies to banking and support. Those who prefer to play their online casino games on-the-go will also
    be thrilled to know that Casino Mate online casino is
    fully optimized to be used on any mobile device that operates Android, iOS,
    or Windows formats. Casino Mate online casino offers multiple safe
    and easy-to-use banking options for their players. These comprehensive benefits combine to
    create a gaming platform that truly understands and addresses the needs of
    modern online casino players.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/casino-hotels-on-the-gold-coast/

  14. I’ve played at a few online casinos before, but this one felt smoother and more local,
    which I liked. From signing up and claiming bonuses,
    to playing your favourite pokies and making secure payments—it all works perfectly on smaller
    screens. With one account, players can move from mobile phone, tablet
    and computer (PC or Mac) with ease. Play pokies on the go with the mobile friendly interface, featuring over 150 mobile casino games.
    PlayCroco games are tested and certified for fairness, so players can rest assured the outcome of any game is as random
    as at their favorite local pub, club or casino.
    By choosing the official PlayCroco Casino website, you gain access to
    a world of entertainment, exclusive promotions,
    and top-notch customer support. Here are some of the best slots to play
    at PlayCroco Casino. New slots are added monthly, so you’ll have the chance
    to play something new regularly. Choose your favorite casino games or try something new from the hundreds of games
    at PlayCroco Casino.
    The website utilizes advanced SSL encryption technology
    to protect players’ personal and financial data, guaranteeing a safe and trustworthy gaming environment.
    The platform is fully optimized for mobile devices, ensuring a smooth gaming
    experience on smartphones and tablets without the need for additional downloads.

    For the mobile casino, access the instant play casino from your Android
    or iOS device’s browser. If you want to play for real money,
    log in and deposit with the cashier.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here