Be A Patron
Be A Patron
HomeNationMaratha reservation: SC gives one week to states to submit brief note...
Nation

Maratha reservation: SC gives one week to states to submit brief note on 50% quota limit, refuses to adjourn hearing

thenews21bureau
By thenews21bureau

@the_news_21

The Supreme Court commenced hearing on Monday on whether the landmark 1992 verdict in the Indira Sawhney case, which caps the quota at 50 per cent, require a re-look by a larger bench.

A five-judge Constitution bench, headed by Justice Ashok Bhushan, gave a week time to all the states to submit their brief note of submissions after some of them sought time.

Senior advocate Arvind Datar, appearing for petitioners who opened the arguments on the question of reference to a larger bench, said there was no need to revisit the Indira Sawhney verdict.

Datar argued that an 11-judge bench needed to be constituted to revisit the verdict, which dealt with several issues, including the cap of 50 per cent quota, adding that it was not required.

Since its inception of the Supreme Court, an 11-judge bench has been constituted only five times to examine issues that are unique and of immense constitutional importance, he said.

Datar said the question raised in the matter was only whether the 50-per-cent quota limit could be breached and not other issues dealt by the 1992 verdict.

“Indira Sawhney (judgement) was delivered with so many deliberations and views that in my humble view it need not be revisited,” Datar said, adding that the 50 per cent cap had been accepted since the verdict.

The bench, also comprising justices L Nageswara Rao, S Abdul Nazeer, Hemant Gupta and S Ravindra Bhat said: “On the request of counsel for different states, we allow one week time to file their brief note of written submissions.” At the outset, senior advocate Jaideep Gupta for Kerala sought adjournment on the ground that assembly elections were on in the state.

The top court rejected his plea and said: “We cannot adjourn the hearing in this case because of the elections.” The bench said it needed to address the issue of the 102nd amendment of the Constitution as it affects every state.

Senior advocate Shekhar Naphade, representing Tamil Nadu, said the court would have to see the special circumstances in which reservation in excess of 50 per cent had been given.

Both Naphade and Gupta said reservation was a policy matter and the hearing on the issue be adjourned due to the elections.

The bench said it was not deciding the factual aspects and would deal with the legal propositions.

On March 8, the top court had framed five questions to be taken up by the constitution bench to consider whether the ‘Mandal verdict’ require a re-look by a larger bench “in the light of subsequent Constitutional amendments, judgments and changed social dynamics of the society”

It had issued notices to all the states on issues of “seminal importance”, including whether the 102nd amendment deprives the state legislatures of its power to enact a law determining the socially and economically backward classes and conferring benefits to them under its enabling power.

The 102nd Constitution inserted Articles 338B, which deals with the structure, duties and powers of the National Commission for Backward Classes, and 342A that deals with the power of the President to notify a particular caste as Socially and Educationally Backward Class and power of Parliament to change the list.

The issue of interpretation of the amendment cropped up before the bench, which is hearing the pleas pertaining to the 2018 Maharashtra law granting reservation to Marathas in education and jobs.

thenews21bureau
thenews21bureau
Previous article
Hemraj Shah: an affable multifaceted personality
Next article
BJP will launch Rs 1 lakh cr road projects in West Bengal if voted to power, says Nitin Gadkari

RELATED ARTICLES

88 COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

spot_img

TheNews21 is a leading national English news portal spear headed by Founder and Editor in Chief Mr. Vivek Bhavsar. Operating from the island city of Mumbai, it covers regional and federal current affairs related to politics apart from major foreign affairs issues. The portal also hosts in-depth investigation features, developments in the business sector, and keeps a pulse on the world of sports and entertainment.

Address: 104, SP Telange Industrial Estate, Opposite Vir Rubber Company, Kalyan-Badlapur Road, Chikhloli,Ambernath - West, Dist Thane, Maharashtra, India 421 501

Quick Links

Popular Articles

Taiwan Seeks ‘Meaningful Dialogue’ With China

SC stays production warrant issued against comedian Munawar Faruqui in case lodged in UP for allegedly hurting religious sentiments

Facebook removes nearly 200 accounts linked to white supremacy groups

Plus 2 lecturers forum meets Principal Secretary Education over New Education policy and other issues

Maharashtra: 1 killed, 8 injured in clash between two groups in Akola; 26 people detained

Maharashtra: Man sets himself ablaze outside Vidhan Bhavan in Mumbai

Ad