Part IX – Controversial tenure of the former civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal : A review of accusations and their consequences

By
Vivek Bhavsar
-
66
1415

X: @vivekbhavsar

Due to our other urgent commitments, I was delayed in releasing Part IX of the ongoing series on the controversial decisions of the then BMC Commissioner, Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal. I apologize to the readers for this delay and am now posting Part IX of the series titled “Controversial Tenure of the Former Civic Chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A Review of Accusations and Their Consequences” today.

Also Read: Part VIII – Controversial tenure of the former civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal : A review of accusations and their consequences

In the ongoing series titled “The Controversial Tenure of Former Civic Chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A Review of Accusations and Their Consequences,” I examine the contentious actions and decisions made by Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal during his time as the BMC Commissioner.

This series seeks to reveal instances of power misuse and neglect of duty by this senior IAS officer, who stands accused of overstepping his authority by granting approvals that exceed his jurisdiction and the provisions of the DCPR 2034, allegedly to benefit certain developers.

Also Read: Part VII : “Controversial tenure of former civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A review of accusations and their consequences”

In this article, I focus on the eighth question I posed to Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal, analysing his response and assessing its relevance and appropriateness. Below, I present the eighth question, his answer, and my analysis, along with the relevant facts.

My Question to Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal:

  1. What steps did you take when it was brought to your attention that this circular was being misused by developers and officials, possibly with your support?

Reply received from Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal to my above Question:

  1. The revision of the circular was to the extent of quantum of penalty on request of stake holders body with due deliberations. The circular contained no other issue, hence there is no question of misuse by the virtue of it. The office of BMC Commissioner does receive lots of representations and complaints and the same are dealt by respective departments on its merit.

Also Read: Part VI : Controversial tenure of the former civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal : A review of accusations and their consequences

My Analysis with the Facts:

It appears that the representatives of CREDAI – MCHI personally met with the then BMC Commissioner Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal. Mr. Chahal made a comment on the letter and forwarded it to the Chief Engineer (Development Planning). The journey of this letter seems to have taken place at an astonishing speed. Kindly check the following table;

Within 8 working days of receiving the letter from CREDAI – MCHI, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), under the leadership of the then BMC Commissioner , Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal, made a decision that caused a loss of hundreds of crores of rupees to the BMC. This decision was taken with such an astonishing speed and in violation of the Maharashtra Government’s “महाराष्ट्र शासन कार्यनियमावली व त्या अन्वये दिलेले अनुदेश”. Furthermore, it breached the procedures laid down and applicable for making financial decisions, despite the existence of the municipal assembly, and unlawfully made a decision to waive fines amounting to hundreds of crores of rupees without having the proper authority.

Also Read: Challenging Integrity : Author’s Response to Accusations from Former Civic Chief Iqbal Singh Chahal

The then BMC Commissioner Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal is expected to answer the following questions promptly regarding the decision to waive a penalty of hundreds of crores without having the authority to do so:

  1. What is the reason for not obtaining the legal opinion and comments from the Law Department of BMC to check the legal aspects of the penalty waiver?
  2. Given that the penalty waiver would strain the municipal treasury and result in a financial loss of hundreds of crores, what is the reason for not obtaining the opinion and comments from the Chief Accountant (Finance) of BMC?
  3. What is the reason for not obtaining the approval of the standing committee for this proposal while the municipal assembly was in existence in the year 2021?
  4. What is the reason for making a decision to waive the penalty without passing a resolution in the municipal assembly and obtaining its approval in 2021?
  5. What is the reason for not sending the proposal to the Maharashtra government through the Urban Development Department for approval, despite the requirement for government approval for the penalty waiver decision?
  6. What is the reason for not assessing how much loss the municipality would incur while waiving the penalty?
  7. The then BMC Commissioner Mr. Chahal cited the reason for the penalty waiver as “due to the real estate slump in this COVID pandemic, which will incentivise and encourage owners/developers to get the free of area merged into habitable areas regularised expeditiously” What is the reason for not preparing rules, about the eligibility of the buildings for regularisation wherein free of FSI areas merged into habitable areas?
  8. What is the reason for regularising illegal constructions in old buildings that were granted occupancy certificates 10 to 15 years ago and against which the court has ordered demolition?
  9. What is the reason for opting to regularise illegal constructions instead of taking action against them and demolishing them?
  10. Did the then BMC Commissioner Mr. Chahal grant illegal penalty waivers solely to regularise the illegal buildings of his friends? Mr. Chahal must clarify this.

Also Read: Part IV : Controversial tenure of civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A review of accusations and their consequences

As an impartial journalist, I considered the possibility that the then Commissioner Mr. Chahal may have mistakenly made the illegal decision regarding the penalty waiver. However, the urgency displayed by Mr. Chahal in making the decision to waive the penalty, which resulted in a loss of hundreds of crores to the BMC, contrasts sharply with the lack of attention he showed to the letters which brought the significant losses incurred by the BMC to his notice. This indicates that the then BMC Commissioner Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal made the illegal decision to waive the penalty consciously and with the sole intent to help his friends and other reason known to him.

Also Read: Part III : Controversial tenure of civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A review of accusations and their consequences

Given the gravity of these allegations, it is crucial to conduct a comprehensive investigation to ensure accountability and transparency within the governance framework. We urge the Chief Minister of Maharashtra Devendra Fadnavis to conduct a diligent inquiry as follows into these matters to maintain the integrity of governance and protect public interest.

  1. To take strict action against the then BMC Commissioner Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal for illegally waiving of penalty and causing a loss of hundreds of crores to the BMC by violating his authority. and,
  2. To investigate the decisions made by Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal during his tenure as the BMC Commissioner through the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). and,
  3. To transfer Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal to a non-executive position from his current position as Additional Chief Secretary (Home) until the investigation is completed.

Also Read: Part II : Controversial tenure of civic chief Iqbal Singh Chahal: A review of accusations and their consequences

In conclusion, the allegations against Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal require serious attention and rectification to restore public confidence in the governance framework. A thorough investigation is essential to address these concerns and to prevent similar issues from arising in the future.

Kindly share your opinion through WhatsApp message on +91 9930403073.

Also Read: Controversial tenure of then civic chief Dr Iqbal Singh Chahal: A review of accusations and their consequences

Do you, the readers, agree that it is essential to establish a precedent that removes any perception of impunity among officials? How important do you think this action is in deterring misconduct within the administrative system and ensuring that no one is above the law, regardless of their position or authority?

In the forthcoming Part “X”, I will delve into the Ninth question posted to Shri Iqbal Singh Chahal, detailing his response and offering my analysis alongside the facts.

Stay tuned for more updates as we continue to unravel this pressing story of Misconduct within government system and abuse of power by Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal, to benefit private parties.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

66 COMMENTS

  1. Ramatogel adalah tempat membawa keberuntungan terbesar di Indonesia dan menyediakan persentase tertinggi mari gabung sekarang di ramatogel dapatkan bonus fantastis setiap hari

  55. Wichtig bei einer Skrill Zahlung ist zu achten, ob diese beim Neukundenbonus ausgeschlossen ist. Seltener zu finden hingegen ist der Bonus ohne Einzahlung oder ein Bonus ohne Umsatzbedingungen. Deshalb ist es wichtig für deutsche Spieler, sich die Bonusbedingungen genau anzusehen. Meist ist der Willkommensbonus an Umsatzbedingungen geknüpft, selbst bei den besten Online Casinos. Zudem bekommt ihr häufig Freispiele für beliebte Automatenspiele dazu. Durch die große Konkurrenz sind die Willkommensboni vielfältig und ihr könnt auch mehrere Angebote annehmen.
    Grundsätzlich ist es jedem selbst überlassen, ob man in deutschen Online Casinos spielen möchte. Jedes Casino, dass in einem EU-Land lizenziert ist, darf nach geltendem EU-Recht (Stand 2025) in Deutschland deutschen Kunden Glücksspiel anbieten. Die strenge Glücksspielvorschriften der deutschen Regierung stellen sicher, dass nur lizenzierte Unternehmen ihre Dienste den Spielern in Deutschland anbieten können. Wichtig ist dabei, nur bei Anbietern zu spielen, die auf der offiziellen GGL-Whitelist stehen – genau diese lizenzierten Anbieter finden Sie in unserer Liste. Mehrere Faktoren tragen dazu bei, ein Online Casino für deutsche Spieler geeignet zu machen, einschließlich der Einhaltung lokaler Vorschriften, Lizenzierung, Zahlungsmethoden, deutschland lizenzierten Spielanbietern und der Verfügbarkeit des deutschsprachigen Kundendienstes.
    Spieler können hier spannende Freispiele und hohe Multiplikatoren mit einem RTP-Wert von 96,71 % erwarten. Das Bwin Casino überzeugt in unserem Bonus Vergleich nicht nur mit einem Willkommensbonus von 100% Gratis Guthaben bis zu 300 € sowie mit 200 Free Spins am beliebten Legacy of Dead Slot. Neuesten Bonusarten zu finden, aber Sie könnten möglicherweise auch an der Rubrik „Exklusiv” interessiert sein, in der spezielle Boni für Casino Guru-Besucher reserviert und vorbereitet sind. Wie bei der Suche nach dem besten Casino können Sie auch hier diese Suchergebnisse anordnen und filtern, sodass Sie die besten Boni für sich herausfinden können. Wenn Sie jedoch neue Casinos bevorzugen und diese angezeigt bekommen möchten, können Sie diese über die Registerkarte „Neu eröffnet” aufrufen und erhalten so die top-aktuellen Optionen für deutsche Spieler.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/willkommen-bei-monro-casino-ihr-einfacher-login/

  56. Wenn Sie die Prepaid-Karte online kaufen, können Sie seit kurzem auch individuelle Beträge wählen. Aktuell ist die Karte in Deutschland sowohl online als auch an zahlreichen Tankstellen, in Supermärkten und an Kiosken erhältlich. Bei Einzahlungen im Online-Casino mit der Paysafecard werden keine Bankdaten an das Casino übermittelt, was für zusätzliche Sicherheit sorgt.
    Parallel können auch Guthaben über mehrere PINs in das Nutzerkonto bei einerTop Casino Appübertragen werden. Nein, dieses Feature steht bei PayPal zur Verfügung und greift auch nicht für Einzahlungen bei Online Casinos. Wer in einem Online Casino für einen Bonus nur 20€ einzahlen will, muss nicht die vollen 100€ übertragen, eine Karte kann mehrfach (bei Restguthaben) eingesetzt werden.
    Mit der 10€ Paysafecard könnt ihr schnelle, sichere und anonyme Einzahlungen ohne Angabe sensibler Zahlungsinformationen abwickeln. Die Paysafecard steht euch nicht in jedem Online-Casino für Einzahlungen ab 10 Euro zur Verfügung. Anschließend hinterlegt ihr die 16-stellige PIN der Wertkarte und bestätigt die Zahlung. Wenn ihr mit 10 Euro Paysafecard im Online Casino spielen wollt, genießt ihr zahlreiche Optionen. Könnt ihr nicht mit 10 Euro Paysafecard im Online Casino spielen, lohnt sich der Blick auf Alternativen. Da diese Lizenz außerhalb Deutschlands gilt, entfallen Beschränkungen wie OASIS oder niedrige Einzahlungslimits – ideal für alle, die sicher und anonym mit der Paysafecard spielen möchten.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/iwild-casino-aktionscode-ihr-schlussel-zu-mehr-spielspas/

  57. Keep in mind that the maximum withdrawal amount depends on the amount of money you can cash out after winning a game. These wagering requirements are easily available with all bonus offers apart from the wager-free offers. Knowing the right factors when choosing no deposit bonus codes can help you win better. Just because you understand how no bonus deposit codes work doesn’t mean you can get the best no deposit bonus codes. We understand that choosing the best no deposit bonus codes for our customers will help them win big.
    If crypto casino gambling sounds intriguing to you, you now know exactly which category of top Australian online casinos you should go for! Much like playing online casino games, investing in cryptocurrencies can be an exhilarating and volatile ride. Most of us would happily redeem a sturdy Australian casino bonus and a few free spins on top every time that we visit Aussie online casinos. Online casino bonuses can be an integral part of a person’s online gambling experience. With the help of our huge number of different online casino categories, you can easily filter out the very best real money casino for you! It is the case for every Australian online casino player that all top online casinos are built differently.
    But for players, a no deposit bonus Australia is an offer worth cashing on given the perks it provides. No deposit casinos are not easily found, at least from legitimate casinos, but they make all the difference in your gambling experience. For more quick transaction casinos, visit our page of the fastest payout online casinos in Australia. To learn more about promotions, visit our page of casino bonuses for Australian players. With that, rest assured that we dig for gambling sites that have superb bonuses ⁠— sometimes even no deposit perks!

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/play-free-slots-%f0%9f%8e%b0-browse-19430-online-slot-games/

  58. Popular Australian banking methods for gambling include a wide variety of payment styles, such as credit cards, crypto, and Neosurf. The best promotions offer huge rewards with minimal rollover requirements. Craps is a simple dice game that has fascinated gamblers for decades. The new law gives eSafety more power to assist with problem gambling. In 2021, Australia passed the Online Safety Act to expand eSafety’s efforts to address cyberbullying and other forms of online harassment. Ca$hed is a dual casino and sportsbook, and it excels in both areas.
    We offer detailed and honest appraisals about the best online casinos in Australia. By following this guide and always focusing on responsible gaming, you’ll be ready for an enjoyable experience in the busy world of Australian online casinos. While some players love playing online slots and pokies, others might prefer classic games like blackjack or roulette. Make sure to check out all the most popular online casino games to make the most of your gaming time! When it comes to online casinos, finding the best site with a minimum deposit that matches your budget is key. But Australians are allowed to play at offshore online casinos because the law targets the operators (the casino), and not you (the player).
    Playing Blackjack online challenges players to achieve a hand closest to the value of 21 without going over. A blend of skill, strategy, and luck, online poker invites players to compete against each other, in a bid to create the best hand or bluff their way to victory. Whether it’s the traditional 3-reels, versatile 5-reels, or the high-stakes progressive jackpots, players are in for a treat with a wide range of options available. If you are looking for the https://blackcoin.co/betonred-online-casino-a-bold-new-place-to-play/ Australia in 2025, you came to the right place. An online casino experience is entirely different from the one down the road.

  59. For frequent players, these events are a rich source of extra value—especially when combined with loyalty tier multipliers and cashback offers. App benefits include app-only free spins, push notifications for promotions and quick login. For players aiming to climb tiers, consistent, responsible play combined with strategic use of promotions tends to be the most reliable path. The platform’s curated lists help players explore recommended pokie picks by provider and theme. Filters allow you to pin down low volatility pokies for longer sessions, or high volatility jackpot slots for big win potential.
    New players at WinSpirit can claim a two-step welcome package up to 2,000 AUD and 100 free spins with wagering terms. Yes — WinSpirit operates under a Curaçao licence and uses SSL encryption, KYC and AML checks to protect players. Following this checklist ensures your first experience with WinSpirit is smooth and informed.
    This promotion features 30 live table games, including Baccarat, Blackjack, Poker, and so on. You can participate in this tournament by wagering just 0.2 AUD and playing 11 games, listed in the promotion details. You can take part in it by playing 116 different games. Such offers revolve around games of specific developers. Our official brand is WinSpirit (sometimes stylised as win spirit), and both terms refer to the same platform. Remember to use the WinSpirit casino login credentials safely, enable any available security features, and consult support for any uncertainties during the process.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/best-online-casino-video-slots-history-and-rules/

  60. Fake casino uses Skycrown’s name to trick people. I noticed some small differences after signing up, like weird payment options and a broken support chat, but by then I’d already… The site looks almost identical – same logo, colors, even the bonus banners – but it’s fake. This casino is a complete scam pretending to be Skycrown. This casino pretends to be Skycrown, but it’s just a fake copy.
    Player loyalty is richly rewarded with plenty of enticing bonuses, tournaments, a loyalty program, and a VIP program. There is a massive selection of games, with over 7,000 to choose from. It’s crucial to enjoy the gambling experience safely, so setting personal limits and taking regular breaks is highly recommended. Enjoy a fair gaming environment and unparalleled excitement – become a part of the winning experience at Skycrown Casino. Alternatively, players can reach out via email for less urgent inquiries.
    SkyCrown has a vast array of deposit and withdrawal options. To claim this, deposits must be over $30, and you’ll need to wager 40X. To get full wagering, you’ll need to bet 30X the amount you won in your free spins. Players can get 30 free spins without adding any money. Let’s look at their promotional offers. Large providers like Winfinity, Atmosfera, and Platipuslive are available.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/best-live-casinos-in-australia-2025-guide/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here