Support Journalism
HomeOPEDDoes the head of state shield dishonest officials in the SRA? 
OPEDTop NewsTrending

Does the head of state shield dishonest officials in the SRA? 

Vivek Bhavsar
By Vivek Bhavsar

X : @vivekbhavsar

PART III

The Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) in Mumbai has been plagued by anomalies in recent times, especially with regard to the appointment and tenure extension of its officers. The mandate of the Government Resolution (GR) dated February 16, 2018, is clear: no official may be extended for more than five years, and they must observe a two-year cooling-off period prior to being reappointed. Recent allegations, however, suggest that certain officials have disregarded this law, including those from the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA) and the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC).

This GR of 16.2.2018 makes it very plain that no extension may be given for longer than a five-year term, after which there must be a two-year cooling-off period observed before re-deputation. However, it appears that certain officials have gotten around this rule, which begs the question of how much protection they have from higher up, such as Chief Minister Eknath Shinde. Critics contend that corrupt practices, such as officials securing their posts through bribes or favours, may occasionally be the cause of term extensions. This circumstance emphasises the necessity of structural changes and constant watchfulness to guarantee that laws are followed and the public’s confidence in the government is preserved.

Irregular Extensions and Alleged Violations

Despite the GR of 2018 requiring a maximum of five years followed by a mandated cooling-off period, the extended deputations of SRA officials and engineers from MHADA pose serious questions regarding accountability and governance. Systemic problems within the administration may be the reason why certain officials have been on deputation for up to 17–18 years, and MHADA engineers for up to 8 years.

The prolonged deputations raise the possibility of protection and favouritism from higher authorities, especially the SRA CEO. This encourages inequity and may result in a lack of faith in the organisation. Long-term deputations may cause stagnation, which lessens the chance that new people and perspectives will be able to further the goals of the SRA. Inefficiencies may also result from officials growing accustomed to their extended roles.

Critics contend that Establish a strong auditing mechanism to keep an eye on deputation terms and make sure rules are being followed. To avoid favouritism and maintain justice, transparent, merit-based procedures for appointments and tenure extensions should be established. Additionally, an independent oversight body should be established to look into and resolve any irregularities in deputations and tenure extensions.  

Permanent Posts and the Question of SRA’s Status

The government recently decided to make thirty percent of the post inside the SRA permanent, which further complicates matters. This development has generated a lot of discussion and was prompted by demands from a Mumbai-based BJP MLA and a former minister of state for urban development. The SRA was founded in 1995 with the intention of eliminating slums from Mumbai. The SRA’s long-term goals are called into question by the recent decision to make thirty percent of the posts permanent. This looks like a conflicting judgement if the SRA is a transient organisation. Why wasn’t this clear from the beginning if the intention was for it to be permanent?

If the SRA was intended to be a permanent establishment, it raises the question of why all 100% posts were not made permanent at its inception in 1995 (Government Notification 16 December 1995). Conversely, if it is a temporary organization, why is there now a push to make 30% of the positions permanent?

If it is a temporary establishment, existing only until Mumbai is made slum-free, why is there a need to make any posts permanent? These inconsistencies point to potential policy missteps by previous governments, including the tenure of Mr. Devendra Fadnavis as Chief Minister of Maharashtra. If the SRA is indeed a permanent entity, why were not all posts made permanent at its inception in 1995?  Critics argue that this selective permanency is an attempt to protect and embed officials who have allegedly engaged in irregular practices. 

Making some of the positions permanent, according to critics, may be an attempt to shield and integrate officials who have allegedly participated in irregular practices, behaviour, guaranteeing their protection and influence going forward. Permanency may jeopardise attempts to confront and correct persistent anomalies in the SRA. If these posts are filled without stringent monitoring and merit-based selections, it might potentially result in a lack of transparency and accountability.  

The decision is a reflection of the government’s inconsistent handling of the goals and organisation of the SRA. Any organisation that has such a significant mission must have well-defined and uniform policies in order to work effectively. The fact that political figures were involved in making this decision shows how much politics influences administrative decisions within the SRA. Critics demand the government clearly defines whether the SRA is a permanent or temporary entity and ensure that all appointments, especially permanent ones, are made through transparent and merit-based procedures.  

The BMC’s Concerns and the Government’s Inaction

The ongoing worries about SRA procedures and the purported shielding of personnel engaged in questionable operations highlight a crucial problem with accountability and governance. Mr. Bhushan Gagrani, the chief of the BMC, emphasised that the government and the BMC had suffered large financial losses as a result of unlawful approvals that were given under these particular regulations. Still, no remedial measures have been implemented.

The lack of action after Mr. Gagrani’s critical communication points to either a lack of responsibility within the SRA or the possibility of outside influence shielding the implicated personnel. The lack of action has raised concerns that these officials are being protected rather than held responsible for their acts by the administration, headed by Chief Minister Shri Eknath Shinde. It is believed that the decision to make thirty percent of SRA positions permanent was made strategically to secure the posts of officials who are suspected of taking part in a scam involving hundreds of crores of rupees. This can strengthen the idea that the highest authorities are watching out for them. 

Critics claim that a substantial decline in public confidence in the government and the SRA may result from ongoing inaction and the appearance of protecting dishonest officials. He goes on to explain that the BMC and the government may face serious consequences as a result of the illicit approvals and the ensuing financial losses, including possible legal challenges and further financial burden. As Mr. Gagrani pointed out, the SRA needs to respond to these improper approvals with swift corrective action. As he requests, this entails rescinding the approvals and paying the accumulated damages.  

Conclusion

The situation within the SRA indeed highlights critical concerns that need to be addressed urgently. The inconsistent extensions of deputations, the selective permanent postings, and the lack of response to grave accusations of financial malfeasance point to underlying systemic problems. Stakeholders and the general public are keeping a careful eye on SRA developments. In order to address these concerns, the government must act decisively and transparently. Failing to do so can strengthen the status quo and erode confidence in the organisation and its leadership. The government can reestablish trust in the SRA and guarantee that it successfully accomplishes its goal of eliminating slums in Mumbai by exhibiting a dedication to transparency, accountability, and good governance.

List of SRA officials serving for more than 5 years

1. R. B. Mitkar, Deputy Chief Engineer (7 years)

2. Sandhya Bawankule, Assistant Registrar (6 years)

3. U.C. Bodke, Executive Engineer (5 years)

4. Milind Wani, Executive Engineer (7 years)

Vivek Bhavsar
Vivek Bhavsar
Vivek Bhavsar is the Editor-in-Chief. He is a senior journalist with more than 30 years of experience in political and investigative journalism. He is the founder and Editor-in-Chief of TheNews21. He has worked with leading English mainline dailies, including The Asian Age and Free Press Journal, and also carries the experience of strides in leading regional newspapers like Lokmat and Saamana. During his stints at reputed vernacular and English-language dailies, he has demonstrated his versatility in covering the gamut of beats from policy-making to urban ecology.  While reporting extensively on socio-political issues across Maharashtra, he found his métier in political journalism as an expert on government policy-making. He made his mark as an investigative journalist with exposes of government corruption and deft analyses of the decisions made in Mantralaya, as exemplified in his series of reports on the multi-crore petrochemical project at Nanar in the state’s Konkan region, which ultimately compelled the government to scrap the enterprise.
Previous article
Javid Qureshi visits fire victims of Rajwar, urges administration for rehabilitation of affected families
Next article
Preventing the inferno – a call to action for fire safety in Jammu and Kashmir

RELATED ARTICLES

84 COMMENTS

  52. Also warum sich mit Einschränkungen zufrieden geben, wenn es so viele Casinos ohne Limits gibt, die ein aufregendes und lohnendes Spielerlebnis bieten können? Diese Casinos bieten den Spielern ein unbeschwertes Spielerlebnis und ermöglichen es ihnen, ihre Leidenschaft für das Spielen voll auszuleben. Insgesamt bieten Online Casinos ohne Einschränkungen den Spielern mehr Freiheit und Flexibilität.
    Je nachdem, wo die Glücksspiellizenz ausgestellt wurde, gelten unterschiedliche Regeln. Alle Anbieter verfügen über eine gültige Glücksspiellizenz und können als 100% seriös und sicher eingestuft werden. Deutsche Casinos mussten sie alle aus dem Programm nehmen und können nur noch Slots im Portfolio anbieten.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/rant-casino-aktionscodes-dein-schlussel-zu-besseren-boni/

  53. Here we have made a list of the currency names you would need to write spellings in order to deposit money against your currency cheques, DD, loan payments or more. Prime factors of a number are the prime numbers that multiply together to form that number. Like all numbers, it has a distinctive mathematical structure.
    Discover the secrets of 999,999,999,999,999,999,999 with our full breakdown of its prime factors, divisors, and mathematical properties… This visualization shows the relative proportions of its 7 prime factors (outer circle), plus the relationship between these and its 256 divisors. You could say that a number is made or ‘composed’ of its prime factors. Its factors, divisors, and base properties can show some interesting behavior.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/how-to-recognise-best-and-worst-online-casinos-easily/

  54. Step into Woo Casino Australia, where every spin feels bigger and every bonus packs a punch. Play on desktop or mobile with the same layout, and always set limits to keep sessions fun and in control. Crypto and card options sit side by side in a clear wallet, and 24/7 live chat keeps help close at hand. The live lobby is deep enough for seasoned table fans, while instant‑win picks keep sessions lively. Game fairness is anchored by studio‑side RNG audits from providers such as Pragmatic Play, Play’n GO, BGaming, and others. Woo Casino is owned and operated by a licensed company, Dama N.V. The E-gaming license number No.
    This powerhouse platform delivers over 2,000 premium online pokies australia titles, lightning-fast PayID payments, and generous bonuses up to AU$1,000 plus 100 free spins. With Curacao licensing, this platform delivers 2,000+ games, fast payouts, and secure gameplay. “Woo Casino promises to woo players with their astounding selection of over one thousand https://blackcoin.co/free-slots-play-32178-online-slot-games-no-download/. This means that you’ll access all games straight from your web browser without downloading any software. These casino game titles have been developed by top-tier software providers, including Amatic, Microgaming, NetEnt, and Pragmatic Play. You can even filter the games by developer, so it’s easy to find your favorites.”
    The mobile site supports Android, iOS, and Windows. Even though there is no telephone support, you can always write a message via live chat or send them an email. All players have the same chances of winnings and rules to follow. Besides, it checks the identity of players. This commission is a major regulatory agency that has strict requirements for online casinos to meet. The Curacao eGaming Commission checked the ins and outs of this casino to make sure it’s safe for Australians to gamble here.

  76. This leads to its second strength: an anthropological rigor. The site treats the rituals and dialects of British power structures with the detached curiosity of a scholar studying a remote tribe. It documents the strange ceremonies (Prime Minister’s Questions as a ritualized shouting contest), the peculiar costumes (the hard hat and hi-vis vest worn for a photo-op at a building site that will never be completed), and the opaque belief systems (the unwavering faith in a “world-leading” initiative launched with no funding). By presenting these familiar elements as anthropological curiosities, PRAT.UK defamiliarizes them, stripping them of their assumed normality and exposing their inherent absurdity. The reader is transformed from a frustrated participant in these rituals into an amused observer of a fascinating, dysfunctional culture. This shift in perspective is itself a form of liberation and the source of a more intellectual, enduring humor.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

spot_img

TheNews21 is India’s independent digital news and investigative platform founded by senior journalist Vivek Bhavsar. From our Mumbai newsroom, we expose corruption, analyse political power, track governance and public policy, and report on issues that directly impact citizens. Alongside investigations, we bring credible coverage of national politics, economy, foreign affairs, business, crime, and civic matters. Our journalism stands firmly on the principles of independence, accuracy, and public interest — No Fear, No Favour.

Quick Links

Popular Articles

Taiwan Seeks ‘Meaningful Dialogue’ With China

SC stays production warrant issued against comedian Munawar Faruqui in case lodged in UP for allegedly hurting religious sentiments

Facebook removes nearly 200 accounts linked to white supremacy groups

Plus 2 lecturers forum meets Principal Secretary Education over New Education policy and other issues

Maharashtra: Man sets himself ablaze outside Vidhan Bhavan in Mumbai

Maharashtra: 1 killed, 8 injured in clash between two groups in Akola; 26 people detained