The Supreme Court has refused to overturn a Madras High Court decision that invalidated a Tamil Nadu government order extending Backward Class Muslim (BCM) reservation benefits to people who converted to Islam from certain Hindu communities.
A bench comprising Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the Tamil Nadu government’s challenge, upholding the High Court’s ruling on eligibility for reservation benefits. The case examined whether people who convert to Islam can claim BCM status on the basis of their social background before conversion.
Supreme Court Explains Reservation Eligibility After Religious Conversion
According to Bar & Bench, the Supreme Court observed that a person moving from the Hindu social order to a non-Hindu social order cannot claim affirmative action under Article 16(4) of the Constitution solely on the basis of social disadvantages associated with their earlier status.
The bench also referred to the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950, which limits Scheduled Caste recognition to people belonging to the specified religious communities under the order, currently Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists. The court further noted that returning to Hinduism would not automatically restore a person’s previous backward-class status.
Tamil Nadu’s 2024 Order Challenged in Court
The dispute arose from a Tamil Nadu government order issued in March 2024. It allowed people who converted to Islam from certain Hindu Backward Class (BC), Most Backward Class (MBC), Denotified Community (DNC) and Scheduled Caste (SC) backgrounds to obtain community certificates under the BCM category.
The state government argued before the Supreme Court that religious conversion does not necessarily eliminate the social and educational disadvantages a person may have experienced because of caste. It maintained that the order was intended to prevent people from losing reservation-related benefits merely because they had adopted Islam.
Tamil Nadu also said the policy followed recommendations from the state Backward Classes Commission and would not disturb the existing reservation framework.
Why the Madras High Court Struck Down the Policy
The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court had ruled against the government order, holding that conversion to Islam does not automatically make a person a member of one of Tamil Nadu’s seven notified Backward Class Muslim communities.
These communities are Ansar, Dekkani Muslims, Dubekula, Labbais—including Rowthers and Marakkayars—Mapilla, Sheik and Syed.
The High Court held that membership in these communities could not be established through religious conversion alone. It treated community identity as distinct from a person’s previous caste background and found the government order inconsistent with applicable legal principles.
Tamil Nadu subsequently approached the Supreme Court on July 6 to challenge the High Court’s decision. The Supreme Court’s dismissal of the state’s plea leaves the High Court ruling in place.
Case Began With Rejection of a Community Certificate
The proceedings originated with a petition filed by Sameer Ahamed, who converted from Hinduism to Islam in 2015. He later applied for a community certificate identifying him as a member of the Muslim Labbai community.
The Tahsildar rejected his application, leading Ahamed to approach the Madras High Court. During the case, the state defended its 2024 policy as a measure to protect people facing social disadvantages despite a change in religion.


