The Supreme Court on Thursday issued notices to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi on a petition filed by Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders challenging alleged irregularities in the Election Commission’s nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi also questioned Gandhi over his march to the Supreme Court on Monday, asking him to explain his conduct. The proceedings covered a separate dispute over the removal of Jantar Mantar in Delhi from the list of designated protest sites, along with restrictions imposed during recent demonstrations.
Supreme Court Seeks Explanation From Rahul Gandhi
During the hearing, the bench said the notice sought on behalf of one petitioner would be considered provisionally, subject to an explanation of his conduct.
The court’s observations followed Gandhi’s participation in a march towards the apex court earlier this week amid opposition protests over the SIR exercise. The bench stressed that judicial proceedings should not be influenced by pressure or demonstrations.
“Nobody can browbeat judiciary,” the court observed, underlining the importance of maintaining the authority and independence of the judicial process.
The petition by Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders seeks action over alleged discrepancies in the electoral roll revision and calls for accountability from the Election Commission leadership.
Delhi Government Asked to Explain Jantar Mantar Decision
The Supreme Court also issued notice to the Delhi government on a plea challenging the de-notification of Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site.
The petitioner sought restoration of the location, which has historically hosted demonstrations by political parties, social organisations and public groups. The court asked the Delhi government to explain why the site had been removed from the list.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the government, told the bench that a committee had previously been formed to examine possible alternative locations for protests in the national capital.
Justice Bagchi questioned the continuing importance of a specific physical protest location in an era when technology has expanded the ways in which people can communicate and make their views heard.
The petitioner’s side argued that demonstrators should have access to a location close to the country’s central administrative institutions. Senior advocate N Hariharan responded that, taken to its logical conclusion, the argument could mean that people might as well protest remotely from places such as Kerala.
Supreme Court Issues Notice to Delhi Police Over Protest Restrictions
The bench also sought a response from the Delhi Police over the use of Sections 172 and 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in connection with the protests.
The proceedings examined the legal basis for restrictions imposed during demonstrations and the question of where public protests should be permitted.
The court heard arguments about whether the location of a protest remains essential when technology allows people to communicate their demands from a distance. The issue arose in the context of demonstrators seeking a recognised site in the national capital.
Government Responds to Concerns Over Women Journalists’ Safety
During the hearing, Mehta said the government supported providing security to women, including women police personnel, amid allegations of sexual violence and harassment involving women journalists at the protests.
He also raised concerns about identifying journalists at demonstrations, arguing that some participants appeared to be recording social media reels, making it difficult to distinguish reporters from other attendees.
The remarks came amid concerns about the safety of women covering or participating in public demonstrations. The allegations and competing claims formed part of the broader discussion surrounding the protests.
INDIA Bloc’s SIR Challenge Comes Before Supreme Court
The notices to the Election Commission leadership were issued as the court considered the INDIA bloc petition concerning the nationwide Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls.
The opposition leaders have alleged irregularities in the exercise and sought accountability from the Election Commission. The notices seek responses from the officials named in the petition; they do not, by themselves, establish that the allegations are proven.
The proceedings also brought questions about protest rights, police restrictions and the conduct of political demonstrations before the court. Responses from the Election Commission, Delhi government and Delhi Police are expected to help the bench examine the issues raised in the respective pleas.


