A murder investigation in Karnataka’s Mandya district has come under scrutiny after a woman who was believed to have been killed nearly seven years ago was found alive. The discovery has raised serious questions about the police investigation, which resulted in an innocent man spending around two-and-a-half years in prison for a murder that never took place.
The woman, identified as Manju, belongs to the Pandavapura area of Mandya. Her disappearance in 2019 led to a missing-person complaint by her father. Two years later, a fresh complaint alleging her abduction and murder triggered a police investigation that ended with the arrest of Rajesh.
However, no body was ever recovered. Manju’s discovery has now turned the case on its head, prompting senior police officials to order an internal inquiry.
How Manju Disappeared in 2019
According to the details of the case, Manju married her maternal uncle, Manjunath, in 2019. The marriage reportedly took place against the backdrop of family circumstances, and she returned to her parental home shortly afterwards.
She went missing on July 3, 2019, following which her father, Nagraj, approached the Pandavapura Police Station and lodged a complaint.
The investigation reportedly remained inactive until 2021, when Nagraj approached the police again with fresh allegations about his daughter’s disappearance.
Two Men Allegedly Told Father His Daughter Was Murdered
On August 11, 2021, Nagraj filed another complaint, claiming that two men, identified as Ananthapadmanabha and Gurukumar, had given him information about Manju’s alleged abduction and murder.
According to the complaint, the two men claimed that a person named Rajesh had abducted Manju and later killed her. They also allegedly told her father that her body had been thrown into the Cauvery River.
Following these allegations, police registered a murder case and reopened the investigation. However, investigators could not recover a body.
Despite the absence of physical evidence in the form of a body, Rajesh was arrested by the then investigating officer, Inspector Prabhakar, who has since retired. Police reportedly conducted inspections at locations in Srirangapatna and Madikeri before filing a chargesheet based on statements from informants and Rajesh’s alleged confession.
Rajesh remained behind bars for approximately two years and five months before securing bail.
Rajesh Alleges Police Torture and Forced Confession
After Manju was found alive, Rajesh claimed that he had been wrongly implicated in a murder case and subjected to physical torture during police custody.
A quarry worker who reportedly earned around Rs 600 a day, Rajesh said his troubles began after he lent his mobile phone to an unidentified person at a bus stand.
He accused the then investigating officer of illegally detaining him and forcing him to confess to a crime he said he had never committed.
“They detained me illegally for 15 days, gave me electric shocks, and kicked me with boots, demanding I confess, threatening to arrest my sister and brother-in-law,” Rajesh told reporters.
He further alleged that police made him recreate the supposed crime scene at locations in Madikeri and Srirangapatna.
Rajesh said the case had severely affected his life and reputation. He claimed that people treated him as a murderer and insulted his parents even though he maintained that he was innocent.
Manju Says She Left Home Because She Was Forced to Marry
Manju, meanwhile, has denied knowing Rajesh or having any connection with the alleged murder described in the police case.
Speaking to reporters after being found, she said her father had arranged her marriage against her wishes, prompting her to leave home and go away with the man she loved.
“My father married me off against my wishes, so I left with the man I loved,” she said.
Manju reportedly lived in Tamil Nadu before returning to Karnataka. She also stated that she married a man named Nagendra at Male Mahadeshwara Hills around six years ago.
She has expressed her willingness to appear before the court and give her statement to clarify the circumstances surrounding her disappearance.
Mandya Police Order Internal Investigation
The discovery has prompted the Mandya police administration to examine how the murder case was investigated and why an innocent person allegedly remained in prison for more than two years.
Superintendent of Police Dr Shobha Rani has directed the Deputy Superintendent of Police to conduct a detailed inquiry into the matter.
“Since an innocent man spent over two years in jail, I have instructed the Deputy SP to conduct a thorough inquiry and submit a report,” SP Dr Shobha Rani said.
The inquiry is expected to examine the handling of the original missing-person complaint, the allegations made in the 2021 complaint, the evidence collected against Rajesh and the circumstances that led to his arrest and chargesheet.
The case has raised serious concerns about investigative procedures, the treatment of accused persons in custody and the consequences of building a murder case without recovering a body or establishing the alleged crime through sufficient evidence.


