Union Home Minister Amit Shah has posed a question to Rahul Gandhi and the Congress that deserves examination. If the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is responsible for the Congress’s electoral difficulties, how does the party explain its prolonged absence from power in several states, stretching back decades before the present controversy?
Shah raised the issue while responding to the Congress and other opposition parties, which have intensified their criticism of the Election Commission of India (ECI). Rahul Gandhi has repeatedly questioned the credibility of electoral processes and alleged that the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has benefited from irregularities.
The Congress maintains that its campaign concerns the integrity of elections, the accuracy of electoral rolls and the independence of a constitutional institution. Shah, on the other hand, argues that the opposition is using the controversy to divert attention from its own electoral failures.
Both arguments raise questions, but they are not necessarily answers to each other. The Congress is entitled to question the Election Commission and demand transparency. At the same time, it cannot explain every political setback through allegations about the electoral process. The party’s decline in several states began long before the current dispute over SIR. Equally, the fact that Congress has suffered repeated electoral defeats does not automatically establish that every concern about voter lists is unfounded.
What Amit Shah Asked
Speaking amid the controversy over electoral rolls, Shah pointed to the Congress’s history of defeats in states where it has struggled to regain power for decades. His argument was that a revision exercise undertaken in recent years could not explain electoral setbacks extending across several generations of political leadership.
It is a question the Congress cannot simply dismiss. But Shah’s criticism also needs to be understood as a political response to a specific controversy. Questions about wrongful deletion of eligible voters, transparency in the revision process and access to remedies require examination on their own merits.
The Election Commission’s constitutional responsibility does not depend on whether the Congress wins or loses. It must administer elections fairly for every party and every eligible voter. The opposition, in turn, has a responsibility to support allegations of wrongdoing with verifiable evidence.
Four Decades Without a Lok Sabha Majority
The Congress’s parliamentary record provides important historical context. The party last secured an outright Lok Sabha majority on its own in the 1984 general election, held following the assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Under Rajiv Gandhi, the Congress failed to secure a majority in the subsequent general elections.
It returned to power in 2004 and 2009 under the leadership of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA), but those governments depended on coalition support. The Congress won 145 Lok Sabha seats in 2004 and 206 in 2009. Its strength then declined sharply to 44 seats in 2014 and 52 in 2019. In 2024, the party improved its tally to 99 seats. The result represented a significant recovery from the previous two general elections, although the Congress remained far from securing a majority on its own.
These figures demonstrate that the party’s political challenges cannot be reduced to a single electoral controversy. They also show that electoral decline is not necessarily permanent. The Congress’s improved performance in 2024 illustrates that parties can recover political ground when circumstances, alliances and voter preferences change.
Also Read: B.P. Ojha: The Commentator Who Played the Game Before He Described It
The States Congress Lost
The decline becomes even more striking when one examines individual states. Tamil Nadu has not had a Congress chief minister since 1967. The rise of Dravidian parties fundamentally transformed the state’s political landscape. In West Bengal, Congress lost power in 1977. The Left Front subsequently dominated state politics for decades before the Trinamool Congress emerged as the principal force.
Uttar Pradesh presents another challenge. Congress has not formed a state government since 1989, while regional parties and the BJP have become central to the state’s electoral politics. Gujarat has remained outside Congress control since the BJP established its dominance in the mid-1990s. Odisha followed a different trajectory, with the Biju Janata Dal governing for nearly a quarter-century before the BJP came to power in 2024. These states cannot be explained through one political formula.
In some, regional parties displaced the Congress. Elsewhere, the BJP built strong organisations and expanded its electoral support. Social coalitions changed, leadership patterns evolved and voters developed new political loyalties. The Congress must study these developments state by state rather than treating its national reputation as sufficient to regain lost ground.
Organisation Matters Beyond Delhi
A political party cannot rebuild itself through press conferences and protests alone. Public demonstrations are an essential democratic instrument. They can draw attention to institutional failures, mobilise supporters and place difficult questions before the government.
But electoral organisation requires sustained work between elections. Parties need credible local leadership, functioning district and booth-level structures, candidates with public standing and a continuous understanding of voters’ concerns.
For the Congress, the challenge is especially difficult in states where an entire generation of voters has grown up without experiencing a Congress government. A party that once dominated national politics must now compete with regional organisations that have developed their own identities and loyal social bases. The Congress’s historical contribution to India may remain significant, but history alone cannot secure contemporary electoral support.
The Election Commission Question Cannot Be Avoided
There is another side to the present confrontation. The Special Intensive Revision has raised questions about the accuracy of electoral rolls, the treatment of voters whose names have been removed and the procedures available for correcting errors. These concerns affect more than political parties. They concern citizens’ ability to exercise their franchise.
The Election Commission must be able to explain the legal basis of its procedures, the safeguards against wrongful exclusions and the mechanisms available to eligible voters seeking restoration of their names. The Congress and other opposition parties must likewise distinguish between documented irregularities, reasonable concerns and allegations that remain unproven.
A credible debate requires records, evidence and transparent procedures rather than competing political accusations. It is therefore possible to recognise the Congress’s organisational weaknesses while also demanding accountability from the Election Commission. Neither question cancels out the other.
A Challenge Beyond Rahul Gandhi
Rahul Gandhi and the Congress leadership face a demanding political task. They must pursue concerns about electoral integrity through constitutional and legal processes. But they must also confront the reasons their party has struggled to regain public support across large parts of the country.
Why have regional parties replaced Congress in several states? Why has its local organisation weakened in some regions? How effectively has it developed state-level leadership? And what political programme can persuade voters who have supported other parties for decades? These questions cannot be answered by blaming an institution. Nor can allegations concerning an institution be dismissed merely by citing the opposition’s electoral defeats.
Amit Shah’s intervention has brought Congress’s historical record back into the discussion. That record deserves scrutiny. But the larger democratic principle is equally important: political parties must earn voters’ confidence, and election authorities must earn public confidence through fairness, transparency and accountability.
The Congress needs to examine its political weaknesses. The Election Commission must answer legitimate questions about electoral procedures. Indian democracy is better served when both responsibilities are taken seriously.


